Top 10 Creepy-Cute Gifts Under $25

Looking for the perfect gift for your spooky friend (or yourself—we don’t judge)? Whether it’s for a birthday, Halloween, or just a little pick-me-up, creepy-cute gifts are the way to go. I’m talking skulls with personality, pastel ghosts, and witchy vibes all wrapped in an aesthetic bow.

Here are 10 creepy-cute gift ideas under $25 that are budget-friendly and full of haunted charm.

💀 1. Drippy Skull Sticker Sheets – $15

My hand-drawn drippy Pokemon skull sticker sheets are the perfect gift for artists, journalers, or spooky souls who love decorating their sketchbooks and laptops. Each sheet has 9 spooky-cute Pokémon-inspired designs printed on glossy photo paper.

👉 Shop on Etsy

🕸 2. Creepy-Cute Coloring Book – $14

Melted Macabre: A Drippy Trippy Coloring Book is packed with 21 creepy skull designs made for adults who love weird, spooky art. It’s a great gift for fans of alternative coloring books and Halloween energy year-round.

👉 Grab it on Lulu or Buy it on Amazon

🖤 3. Gothic Cat Plush – ~$10

Soft, spooky, and way too cute. A bat-winged or ghost cat plushie is the perfect desk buddy or shelf accent for any creepy-cute collector.

👉 Amazon pick

🖼 4. 5x7 Drippy Skull Mini Print – $15

Add some haunted charm to your walls or bookshelf with a small-format drippy skull art print. Great for building a spooky gallery wall or gifting as part of a mini art bundle.

👉 Available on Etsy

🦇 5. Bat-Themed Enamel Pins – $9

Add a little flair to your jacket, backpack, or pin board. Bat and ghost enamel pins with pastel or glitter finishes make great add-on gifts.

👉 Amazon pick

📚 6. Creepy Coloring Books for Adults – $15

If you love coloring outside the lines, there are tons of eerie and elegant adult coloring books on Amazon. Pair one with a gel pen set or Prismacolors.

👉 Amazon creepy coloring book pick

✉ 7. Custom Drippy Art Trading Cards – $22

Unique and collectible, my handmade drippy Pokémon-style art cards are a spooky twist on a childhood favorite. Each one is designed, printed, cut, and packed by hand.

👉 Browse on Etsy

🕯 8. LED Flickering Candles – ~$10

Set the haunted mood with battery-powered LED candles—safe, cozy, and cute. Great for dorms, bedrooms, or alt workspaces.

👉 Amazon pick

🌙 9. Witchy Sticker Books / Journals – ~$10–$20

Perfect for organizing your sticker collection or journaling your witchy thoughts. Some even come with spooky illustrations built in.

👉 The Green Witch’s Sticker Book: 600+ Enchanting Stickers Inspired by Green Magic

👉 Sticker Studio: Apothecary: A Sticker Gallery for Modern Mystics

👉 Mystical Ephemera! An Enchanting Vintage Sticker Book

👉 Wicca Sticker Book: More than 400 Magickal & Mystical Stickers

🎀 10. Skull Planters (Mini Size) – ~$20–$25

Tiny skull-shaped planters are the perfect blend of creepy and cute. Fill one with a little faux plant or candy for a complete gift idea.

👉 Skull Planter with Drain Hole

👉 Skull Potted Plant Head Planter

👉 Simcat Succulent Pots with Drainage Mini Creative Skull Decor

👉 VanEnjoy Set of 3 Ceramic Skull succulent Pots and Planters

✨ Wrap It Up: Build a Bundle

Want to go the extra mile? Combine a sticker sheet, mini print, and a plush or pin for a totally unique spooky gift set—wrapped in black tissue and sealed with creepy washi tape, of course.

💌 Want More Ideas Like This?

🎨 Follow me on Instagram, TikTok, YouTube Shorts, and BlueSky
🔮 I post gift guides, behind-the-scenes art, and spooky content all year long!

Illy

Hi, I'm Sarah (Illy)! I'm an illustrator and graphic designer from Buffalo, NY with over 18 years of experience bringing creative ideas to life. Whether it's a bold logo, a unique design for your business, or an eye-catching piece of art for social media, I thrive on making visuals that stand out.

I specialize in creating illustrations with a twist—my recent work focuses on drippy skulls, floral designs, and a touch of the unconventional. I love working with musicians and small businesses to create merch, promotional graphics, and everything in between.

My goal is to help you tell your story through striking designs that capture attention and leave a lasting impression. If you're looking for a creative partner who is passionate, dependable, and ready to tackle any project, let's chat!

https://www.illymakes.com
Next
Next

Goth and Alternative Books I Recommend (for Artists + Creatives)