How I Started Selling My Art Online (And What I Wish I Knew)

Selling my art online started with one simple idea: I want to share the weird, spooky stuff I love with other people who get it.

Now, I run my own art shop, I’ve published a coloring book, and I create daily content that reaches fellow creepy-cute lovers all over the world. But it didn’t happen overnight—and there were a lot of things I had to learn the hard way.

If you’re just starting out (or thinking about it), here’s the real story of how I got started selling my art online—and the biggest things I wish I’d known when I was just getting started.

🕸 Step 1: I Just Started Posting

At first, I didn’t have a website or Etsy shop—I just started posting my artwork on Instagram. It wasn’t curated, it wasn’t branded… it was just me, sharing things I was proud of.

Over time, people started asking:
“Is this for sale?”
“Can I get this as a sticker?”

That’s when I realized there might actually be a market for the creepy-cute, drippy skull vibe I love creating.

👉 Pro tip: You don’t need to be perfect. Just start sharing. The right people will find you.

💀 Step 2: I Opened My Etsy Shop

I chose Etsy because it was beginner-friendly, already had a built-in audience, and let me test ideas without needing a whole website upfront. I listed my first few sticker designs and some prints… and slowly but surely, orders started coming in.

👉 What I wish I knew: Take time to write clear product descriptions, use relevant keywords, and photograph your work well. Good photos and SEO matter more than you think.

📦 Step 3: I Got the Right Tools

Once orders picked up, I realized I needed a better setup. I invested in a few key tools to make things smoother:

  • Thermal label printer – no ink, super fast

  • Digital shipping scale – avoids overpaying for postage

  • Sticker paper + laminate sheets – for making my own stickers

  • Cricut + cutting mat – for clean sticker cuts

👉 Amazon picks:

✨ Step 4: I Created a Brand Around My Aesthetic

That’s when illymakes really came to life. I leaned fully into what made my work unique:

  • Drippy skulls

  • Creepy-cute twists on nostalgic characters

  • Bright color palettes with a goth undertone

  • A mix of spooky, fun, and a little weird

I created matching product packaging, and made sure my Instagram, Etsy, and blog all had the same feel.

👉 What I wish I knew: Branding doesn’t have to be complicated—just be consistent with your vibe and visuals, and the rest will come together.

🖤 Step 5: I Expanded to New Products + Platforms

After stickers and prints, I added:

I also started using Amazon affiliate links for tools I genuinely use. This helps support my work while giving followers easy access to products I trust.

👉 Check out my coloring book here
👉 Follow me on Instagram and TikTok for more behind-the-scenes

💡 What I Wish I Knew Sooner

Here are a few things I’ve learned along the way:
✔ You don’t need to wait until you’re “ready.”
✔ Done is better than perfect.
✔ Every post doesn’t have to go viral—just be you.
✔ Your audience will grow if you keep showing up and connecting.
✔ There is a market for your weird, wonderful art.

🛍 Want to Start Your Own Shop?

Check out my favorite art products here:
My stickers, prints, shirts, magnets, and trading cards on Etsy

And don’t forget to follow me on socials for more spooky cute art biz tips:
🎨 Instagram
🎃 TikTok
🕷 YouTube Shorts
🌙 LinkTree

Illy

Hi, I'm Sarah (Illy)! I'm an illustrator and graphic designer from Buffalo, NY with over 18 years of experience bringing creative ideas to life. Whether it's a bold logo, a unique design for your business, or an eye-catching piece of art for social media, I thrive on making visuals that stand out.

I specialize in creating illustrations with a twist—my recent work focuses on drippy skulls, floral designs, and a touch of the unconventional. I love working with musicians and small businesses to create merch, promotional graphics, and everything in between.

My goal is to help you tell your story through striking designs that capture attention and leave a lasting impression. If you're looking for a creative partner who is passionate, dependable, and ready to tackle any project, let's chat!

https://www.illymakes.com
Previous
Previous

Spooky-Cute Self Care: Art, Journals, Candles, and Chill

Next
Next

Top 10 Creepy-Cute Gifts Under $25